How To Choose Between Fixed and Variable-Rate Mortgages

We get it — the home-buying journey is exhilarating! However, amidst open houses and dream kitchens, there’s a less glamorous — yet crucial — decision waiting for you: choosing the right mortgage rate. You can think of it like a compass that will guide your financial ship through the seas of homeownership. So, do you play it safe with a fixed mortgage rate or ride the waves with a variable rate?
Let’s break it down. A fixed mortgage rate is like a steady breeze, keeping your payments consistent throughout the term of your loan. The certainty it offers is like a comfort blanket for your budget, allowing you to plan for life’s other adventures without surprise costs.
On the flip side, a variable mortgage rate is more like the wind in your sails, changing with the financial currents. It can lead to pleasant surprises, like lower payments when rates drop, but it can also test your resilience if the financial tides turn, and rates go up.
Most homebuyers lean toward fixed-rate mortgages for the financial security they offer, especially if they’re setting roots for the long term. However, the popularity of a mortgage type is less important than how well it aligns with your personal financial landscape.

Fixed-Rate Mortgages: Safe and Predictable

Rates on a fixed-rate mortgage stay the same for the loan’s entire repayment term — steady, unchanging, reliable. They are the traditional go-to for many homeowners, and here’s why they might be the right choice for you.
Advantages of Fixed-Rate Mortgages
Disadvantages of Fixed-Rate Mortgages
Financial Clarity: A fixed-rate mortgage simplifies your financial planning. Like clockwork, your payments remain the same month after month, year after year, allowing you to budget with pinpoint accuracy.
Higher Starting Rates: Often, the trade-off for stability is a higher initial rate. It’s like paying for an insurance policy against future rate hikes.
Shelter from Rate Increases: No matter how the economy twists and turns, your interest rate stays the same. While others might feel the pinch of increased rates, you’ll rest easy knowing your rate is set in stone.
Less Flexibility: If rates fall, you won’t automatically reap the benefits. You’d need to refinance to take advantage of lower rates, which comes with its own costs and considerations.
Long-Term Savings: If you lock in a low rate at the right time, you could potentially save thousands over the life of your loan compared to variable rates in a rising market.
Potential Prepayment Penalties: Exiting a fixed-rate mortgage early can come at a cost. If life throws a curveball and you need to sell or refinance, you might face financial penalties.

Common Fixed-Rate Mortgages Include:

  • 30-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgage: This is the standard bearer of mortgage terms, offering the lowest monthly payments over the long haul because the loan balance is spread over three decades. The trade-off? You’ll pay more in interest over the life of the loan compared to shorter terms. However, the lower monthly payment could free up cash for other investments or expenses.
  • 15-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgages: If you’re looking to save on interest and are comfortable with a higher monthly payment, a 15-year term could be a great fit. You’ll build equity faster and pay less interest because the loan is amortized over a shorter period. It’s a compelling choice for those looking to own their home outright sooner and save for other long-term goals.
  • Other Term Lengths: While 30-year and 15-year terms are the most popular, mortgages with 20-year, 25-year, or even 10-year terms are also available, offering a middle ground between the lower payments of a 30-year term and the rapid equity build-up of a 15-year term.

CUSO’s Expert Advice and Tips:

  • Rate Isn’t Everything: Consider the overall cost of the mortgage, including fees and penalties, not just the interest rate.
  • Future Plans Matter: If you’re planning to stay put for a long time, the fixed-rate mortgage could be your best bet. But if you’re thinking you won’t stay in a certain market for long, weigh the potential costs of breaking your mortgage.
  • Lock In Wisely: The term you choose for your fixed-rate mortgage can affect your rate. Shorter terms often have higher rates due to the uncertainty of rate movements. Longer terms, though potentially more costly upfront, could save you money in an environment where rates are rising, or expected to rise.
  • Negotiate Terms: Some terms of a mortgage are negotiable. This includes not only the rate but also payment privileges like lump sum payments, which can help you pay down your mortgage faster without incurring penalties.
  • Read the Fine Print: Pay special attention to the terms regarding portability and assumability, which can be significant if you decide to sell or transfer your mortgage to another property. Also, be on the lookout for balloon payments — large sums due at the end of the mortgage term.

Variable-Rate Mortgages: The Flexible Challenger

With a variable-rate mortgage, your rate may go up or down based on market trends, reflecting changes in the lender’s prime rate. This option could be appealing if you’re looking to capitalize on potential decreases in interest rates.
Advantages of Variable-Rate Mortgages
Disadvantages of Variable-Rate Mortgages
Starting Rate Advantage: Variable rates often start lower than their fixed-rate counterparts, offering initial cost savings that can be attractive for budget-conscious borrowers.
Unpredictability: The primary drawback is uncertainty. Your payments can increase if the interest rates rise, which might strain your monthly budget.
Potential Long-Term Savings: If interest rates decline, you could find yourself paying less over time compared to a fixed-rate mortgage. This can result in considerable interest savings throughout the course of your loan.
Complex Budget Planning: With payments that can fluctuate, managing your monthly budget requires more effort and a financial cushion for potential increases.
Flexibility:Variable rates typically come with fewer restrictions on prepayment, allowing you to make extra payments or pay off your loan early without hefty penalties.
Market Vulnerability: Economic downturns or rate hikes can increase your payment amounts, which may be challenging if not factored into your financial planning.

Common Variable-Rate Mortgages Include:

  • Standard Variable-Rate Mortgages: These mortgages change in accordance with the prime rate, meaning your monthly payments will vary as interest rates shift.
  • Adjustable-Rate Mortgages (ARMs): With ARMs, your payments adjust directly with rate changes, which means your payment could increase or decrease more significantly with market fluctuations.
  • Capped Rate Mortgages: These offer a variable rate with a ceiling, ensuring that your rate won’t exceed a certain point, which provides a safety net in volatile markets.

CUSO’s Expert Advice and Tips:

  • Rate Cap: If opting for a variable-rate mortgage, find out if there is a cap that will protect you from soaring interest rates, providing a safety buffer.
  • Shorter Terms for Flexibility: Consider shorter-term variable-rate mortgages if you want the option to reassess your mortgage as the market changes without being tied to a long-term agreement.
  • Monitor the Market: Stay informed about economic trends and central bank decisions, as these will directly affect your mortgage payments.
  • Plan for Rate Changes: Keep a buffer in your budget for potential increases in payments. Use online mortgage calculators to understand the impact of rate changes on your monthly obligations.
  • Conversion Options: Make sure you understand your options to convert to a fixed-rate mortgage if the variable rate becomes unmanageable.

How to Choose?

Deciding between fixed and variable rates isn’t just about crunching numbers — it’s about assessing your lifestyle and financial goals. When deciding which option to choose, consider answering these questions:
  • How much risk can I comfortably take on?
  • Do I have the flexibility in my budget to accommodate potential rate increases?
  • How long do I plan to live in this home?
  • Am I planning for other major financial events that require stability in my expenses?

CUSO's Commitment to Guiding You

At CUSO, we understand that everyone’s financial situation is unique. That’s why we offer personalized guidance tailored to your circumstances. Our financial experts are here to walk you through the details of each mortgage option, ensuring that you choose the path that best aligns with your financial aspirations and home ownership dreams.

Beyond the term of the loan, borrowers also have lots of options when it comes to the type of loan they get. Click here for more Information on all the loan options CUSO provides or talk to one of our loan officers who can help guide you to the right decision!

Share the Post:

Related Posts